FANDOM


Red John is, quite simply, a homicial genius. He influences people to do his bidding. Why have so many people died for this man? Why are they willing to give up their lives just to lead Jane on the wrong path?

We now know, for sure, that Red John is present on the list of seven suspects. Now, if Red John was more than one person, It would make sense (He is many), but I think Red John being one person would call for a much more "epic" showdown between the two archenemies. 

List:

  1. Bret Stiles
  2. Gale Bertram
  3. Raymond Haffner
  4. Reede Smith
  5. Bob Kirkland
  6. Sheriff Thomas McCallister
  7. Brett Partridge

Moments before Rebecca's (For those who don't remember, the crazy woman who killed Bosco and two of his agents) murder, she smiles, making it seem that the man who poisoned her was, indeed, Red John. His hair looks dark brown and his body lean. He had to have been strong to lift up Jane and his chair in the season two finale.

Red John also has to be able to change his voice to a higher pitch, and with some of the suspects, that's impossible.

Which means we can rule out some of the suspects. (Ones who probably can't lift up Jane, and probably can't change their voice all that much, to what Red John sounds like)

Updated List:


  1. Bret Stiles
  2. Gale Bertram
  3. Raymond Haffner
  4. Reede Smith
  5. Bob Kirkland
  6. Sheriff Thomas McCallister
  7. Brett Partridge


We have now narrowed down the list to three specific names. All possible suspects of Red John. However, I have strong doubts that Bob Kirkland is Red John, as that would be incredibly obvious. 

I now think that these are the most likely people to be Red John:

Updated List:

  1. Raymond Haffner
  2. Brett Partridge
  3. Bob Kirkland

I strongly believe that Bertram and Kirkland are accomplices, or want Red John for a different reason. I think that every name on that list has connections to Red John. 

In the end, I believe and hope that Brett is Red John. I think it would make for a great standoff.

Who do you think is Red John? Why?

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.